Questoes comentadas/Estatuto da Criança e do Adolescente

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Processo de Apuração de Ato Infracional

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abDababoabbabrabcababbaboabsab,ab ab1ab7ab ababnaboabsab,ab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbaboabnabdabeab abab abpabuabbab aboabbabraboabcababbabeabsabsaboab abdabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdabeab ababtaboab abiabnabfaboabbabrababcababbabiaboabnabablab.ab abSabeabgabuabnabdaboab abab aboabbabrabeabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababcababbaboab,ab aboab ababdaboablabeabsabcababbabeabnabtabeab abfaboabiab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabeabnabdabiabdaboab abqabuababnabdaboab abeabsabtababvabab absabuabbabtaboabbabrababiabnabdaboab abbabeabnabsab abdabeab abuabmab abeabsabtababbabeablabeabcababbabiabmabeabnabtaboab abcababbaboabmabeaboabbabrabcababbabiabablab.ab abAabsabsabiabmab,ab abfaboabiab-ablabhababbabeab abiabmabpabuabbabtababdabab abab abcababbaboabnabdabuabtabab ababnabablaboabgabab ababoab abAaboabbabrabtab.ab ab1ab5ab5ab abdaboab abCab aboabdabiabgaboab abPabeabnabablab ab(abfabuaboabbabrabtaboab)ab.ab abDababoabbabrabiababnabab,ab ab4ab0ab ababnaboabsab,ab abmababeab abdabeab abDababoabbabrabcababbaboabsab,ab aboab(abab)ab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabuaboabbabrabab,ab abnabab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboab abdabeab ababdabvaboabgababdaboab(abab)ab,ab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abfababzabeaboabbabrab abab abdabeabfabeabsabab.ab abDabeabsabiabgabnababdabab ababuabdabiabeabnabcababbabiabab abdabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababcababbaboab,ab abeabsabtababvababmab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtabeabsab abDababoabbabrabcababbaboabsab,ab abDababoabbabrabiababnabab abeab ababsab abtabeabsabtabeabmabuabnabhababbabsab abdabeab ababcababbabuabsababcababbaboab.ab abTababnabtaboab abDababoabbabrabcababbaboabsab abqabuababnabtaboab abDababoabbabrabiababnabab abcababbaboabnabfabiaboabbabrabmababoabbabrababmab,ab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrababnabtabeab abab ababuabtaboabbabrabiabdababdabeab aboabbabjabuabdabiabcababbabiababoabbabrabiabab,ab abqabuabeab abvaboabcababbabeab abfababoabbabrabab abab abdabeabfabeabsabab abtabeabcababbabnabiabcababbab abnababqabuabeablabeab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabeabsabsaboab.ab abEabnabtaboabbabrabeabtababnabtaboab,ab aboab:abuabiabzaboab abvabeaboabbabrabiabfabiabcababbaboabuab abqabuabeab abnababoab abhababbab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabuaboabbabrababcababbaboab aboabbabjabuabnabtababdabab ababoabsab ababuabtaboabsab.ab abPaboabbabrab abiabsabsaboab,ab aboab abeabxabcababbablabuabiabuab abdaboab abfabeabiabtaboab abeab abnaboabmabeaboabuab abab abDabeabfabeabnabsaboabbabrabiabab abPabuabbablabiab abcababbab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abpabuabbababtaboabbabraboabcababbabiabnababoabbabrab aboabsab abiabnabtabeaboabbabrabeabsabsabeabsab abdaboab ababdaboablabeabsabcababbabeabnabtabeab,ab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrabab abab abvaboabnabtababdabeab abdabeabsabtabeab abeab abdabeab absabuabab abgabeabnabiabtaboabbabrabab.ab abCaboabnabsabiabdabeaboabbabrababnabdaboab aboab abcababbabsaboab ababcababbabiabmabab abnababoabbabraboabbabrababdaboab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtab abab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abOab abDababgabiabsabtaboabbabrababdaboab abeaboabbabraboabbabraboabuab ababoab abnaboabmabeababoabbabrab abab abDabeabfabeabnabsaboabbabrabiabab abPabuabbablabiabcababbab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab abdabeabvabeaboabbabrabiabab abtabeaboabbabrab ababdabiababdaboab abab ababuabdabiabeabnabcababbabiabab abeab abdababdaboab abuabmab abpabuabbaboabbabrababzaboab aboabbabrababzaboababvabeablab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab aboabbabjabuabnabtababdabab abdabab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabuaboabbabrababcababbaboab.ab
  2. B.
    abCaboabnabsabiabdabeaboabbabrababnabdaboab abab ababuabsabeabnabcababbabiabab abdabeab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabuaboabbabrababcababbaboab,ab aboab ababdaboablabeabsabcababbabeabnabtabeab abeabsabtababvabab abiabnabdabeabfabeabsaboab,ab abdabeab abmaboabdaboab abqabuabeab aboab:abuabiabzaboab ababgabiabuab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtababmabeabnabtabeab ababoab abnaboabmabeababoabbabrab abab abDabeabfabeabnabsaboabbabrabiabab abPabuabbablabiabcababbab.ab
  3. C.
    abOab abDababgabiabsabtaboabbabrababdaboab abeaboabbabraboabbabraboabuab,ab abuabmabab abvabeabzab abqabuabeab abeab abdabiabsabpabuabbabeabnabsababdabab abab aboabuabtaboabbabrabgabab abdabeab abmababnabdababtaboab abqabuababnabdaboab aboab ababdabvaboabgababdaboab(abab)ab abcababbaboabnabsabtabiabtabuabiabdaboab(abab)ab abtabiabvabeaboabbabrab absabiabdaboab abiabnabdabiabcababbabdaboab(abab)ab abpabuabbaboabbabrab aboabcababbabsabiababoab abdabeab ababtaboab abfaboabbabrabmabablab abcababbaboabmab abab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabcababbab abdabab ababuabtaboabbabrabiabdababdabeab aboabbabjabuabdabiabcababbabiababoabbabrabiabab.ab
  4. D.
    abOab:abuabiabzaboab abeaboabbabraboabbabraboabuab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab abdabeabvabeaboabbabrabiabab ababdabiababoabbabrab aboab ababtaboab abeab aboabfabiabcababbabiababoabbabrab abab abOabAabBab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab ababpabuabbaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdabeab abeabvabeabnabtabuabablab abiabnabfaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdabiabsabcababbabiabpabuabbablabiabnababoabbabrab,ab aboabbabjabab abqabuabeab aboab ababdabvaboabgababdaboab(abab)ab abnababoab abpabuabbaboabdabeaboabbabrabiabab absabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababoabbabrab abnabab ababuabdabiabeabnabcababbabiabab absabeabmab abab aboabbabjabuabnabtababdabab abdabab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbabeabcababbabtabiabvabab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabuaboabbabrababcababbaboab.ab ab4ab5ab aboab abEabXabAabMabEab abDabOab abOabRabDabEabMab abUabNabIabFabIabCabAabDabOab abTabiabpabuabbaboab abBaboabbabrababnabcababbab ab–ab abPabáabgabiabnabab ab1ab4ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa C está correta porque a indicação de defensor em ato formal perante a autoridade judiciária (conhecida como mandato apud acta) dispensa a apresentação de procuração escrita, conforme aplicação analógica do Art. 266 do CPP e os princípios da ampla defesa e da livre escolha do defensor.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A alternativa A está incorreta porque o magistrado não deveria adiar a audiência, mas sim aceitar a representação do advogado ali mesmo, sem necessidade de prazo para juntada de procuração.
A alternativa B está incorreta porque o adolescente não estava indefeso, já que manifestou expressamente o desejo de ser representado pelo advogado presente, tornando a nomeação da Defensoria Pública uma violação ao direito de escolha de defensor.
A alternativa D está incorreta porque não há qualquer infração disciplinar a ser apurada pela OAB, visto que a atuação do advogado sem procuração escrita é plenamente legítima quando constituído oralmente em audiência.

Base legal

Artigo 266 do Código de Processo Penal (CPP), aplicável subsidiariamente ao rito do ECA, e Artigo 5º, inciso LV, da Constituição Federal de 1988.