Questoes comentadas/Etica Profissional

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Advogado Empregado

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abAab ababdabvaboabgababdababJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abfaboabiab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtababdabab abpabuabbabeablabab absaboabcababbabiabeabdababdabeab abeabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsababoabbabrabiabab abdabeab abtabeablabeabfaboabnabiabab abAablabfabab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboabbabrab ab1ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abcababbaboabnabtabiabnabuababsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abdabiabab,ab abdabeab absabeabgabuabnabdabab abab abqabuabiabnabtabab-abfabeabiaboabbabrabab,ab abtaboabtabablabiabzababnabdaboab ab4ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab absabeabmababnababiabsab.ab abAablabeabmab abdabiabsab absaboab,ab aboab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab abeabsabcababbaboabbabrabiabtaboab abfabiaboabbabrabmababdaboab abeabnabtaboabbabrabeabJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abeab abab absaboabcababbabiabeabdababdabeab abeabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsababoabbabrabiabab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabvabeab abqabuabeab,ab abeabmab absabiabtabuababcababbaboabeabsab abeabxabcababbabeabpabuabbabcababbabiaboabnababiabsab,ab abeablabab abdabeabvabeaboabbabrabab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboabbabrab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab,ab absabeabnabdaboab aboabbabrabeabmabuabnabeaboabbabrababdabab abcababbaboabmab abuabmab ababdabiabcababbabiaboabnabablab abdabeab ab5ab0abйab absaboabbaboabbabrabeab aboab abvabablaboabbabrab abdabab abhababbaboabbabrabab abnaboabbabrabmabablab.abJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abqabuabeabsabtabiaboabnabab abab abvabablabiabdababdabeab abdabeabsabsababsab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtabuababiabsab,ab abeabsabpabuabbabeabcababbabiabablabmabeabnabtabeab abeabmab aboabbabrabeablababcababbaboab abab abdabuaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdabab aboabbabjaboabbabrabnababdabab abdabeab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboab abeab abab aboabbabrabeabmabuabnabeaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdababsab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab.ab abCaboabmab abbababsabeab abnaboab abAaboabbabrabtab.ab ab2ab0ab abdaboab abEabsabtababtabuabtaboab abdabab abAabdabvaboabcababbabcababbabiabab abeab abdabab abOabAabBab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abOab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab abdabeabJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abeab abvabablabiabdaboab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab abab aboabbabjaboabbabrabnababdabab absabeabmababnabablab abnababoab abuablabtaboabbabrababpabuabbababsabsabab ab4ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab,ab abeab ababsab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab abpabuabbaboabdabeabmab absabeaboabbabrab aboabbabrabeabmabuabnabeaboabbabrababdababsab abcababbaboabmab abuabmab ababdabiabcababbabiaboabnabablab abdabeab ab5ab0abйab abcababbaboabnabfaboabbabrabmabeab abeabsabtabiabpabuabbablababdaboab abnaboab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab.ab
  2. B.
    abAab absaboabcababbabiabeabdababdabeab abeabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsababoabbabrabiabab abeabsabtabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab ababoab abfabiabxababoabbabrab ab1ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abdabeab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abdabiabab,ab abdabeabsabdabeab abqabuabeabJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abcababbabuabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabab ababpabuabbabeabnababsab abqabuababtaboabbabraboab abdabiababsab abdabeab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab absabeabmababnabab,ab absabeabmab abab abnabeabcababbabeabsabsabiabdababdabeab abdabeab abpabuabbababgababmabeabnabtaboab abdabeab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab.ab
  3. C.
    abOab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab abdabeabJabeabsabsabiabcababbab abeab abiabnabvabablabiabdaboab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab abab aboabbabjaboabbabrabnababdabab abdabiababoabbabrabiabab abnababoab abpabuabbaboabdabeab abeabxabcababbabeabdabeaboabbabrab ab8ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abcababbaboabnabtabiabnabuababsab,ab abeab ababsab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab abdabeabvabeabmab absabeaboabbabrab aboabbabrabeabmabuabnabeaboabbabrababdababsab abcababbaboabmab abuabmab ababdabiabcababbabiaboabnabablab abdabeab ab1ab0ab0abйab,ab abcababbaboabnabfaboabbabrabmabeab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabvabiabsabtaboab abnaboab abEabsabtababtabuabtaboab abdabab abOabAabBab,ab abiabnabdabeabpabuabbabeabnabdabeabnabtabeabmabeabnabtabeab abdaboab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab abfabiaboabbabrabmababdaboab.ab
  4. D.
    abAab absaboabcababbabiabeabdababdabeab abeabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsababoabbabrabiabab abeabsabtabab ababgabiabnabdaboab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtababmabeabnabtabeab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab:abeabsabsabiabcababbab abab abpabuabbaboabdabeab abtaboabbabrababbabablabhababbaboabbabrab ababtabeab ab1ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abdabiabab abdabeabsabdabeab abqabuabeab absabuabab aboabbabjaboabbabrabnababdabab absabeabmababnabablab abnababoab abuablabtaboabbabrababpabuabbababsabsabeab ab4ab0ab abhababbaboabbabrababsab,ab abmababsab abab aboabbabrabeabmabuabnabeaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdababsab abhababbaboabbabrababsab abeabxabtaboabbabrababsab abdabeabvabeaboabbabrabiabab absabeaboabbabrab abdabeab ab1ab0ab0abйab absaboabbaboabbabrabeab aboab abvabablaboabbabrab abdabab abhababbaboabbabrabab abnaboabbabrabmabablab,ab abiabnabdabeabpabuabbabeabnabdabeabnabtabeabmabeabnabtabeab abdaboab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtaboab abeabsabcababbaboabbabrabiabtaboab.ab ab4ab5ab aboab abEabXabAabMabEab abDabOab abOabRabDabEabMab abUabNabIabFabIabCabAabDabOab abTabiabpabuabbaboab abBaboabbabrababnabcababbab ab–ab abPabáabgabiabnabab ab4ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa C está correta porque, nos termos do Art. 20 da Lei nº 8.906/94 (Estatuto da OAB), a jornada do advogado empregado não pode exceder 4 horas diárias (ou 8 horas em caso de dedicação exclusiva), tornando inválida a jornada contratual de 10 horas diárias. Além disso, o § 2º do mesmo artigo impõe que as horas extras sejam pagas com adicional mínimo de 100%, invalidando a previsão contratual de 50%.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A alternativa A está incorreta pois valida a jornada diária de 10 horas e o adicional de 50%, ambos contrários aos limites legais de 8 horas (limite máximo na dedicação exclusiva) e 100% de adicional.
A alternativa B está incorreta porque a compensação para 10 horas diárias é ilegal, visto que extrapola o limite diário improrrogável de 8 horas para o advogado empregado.
A alternativa D está incorreta ao afirmar que a empresa agiu corretamente ao fixar a jornada de 10 horas diárias, o que viola o limite máximo diário estabelecido pela legislação profissional.

Base legal

Artigo 20, caput e § 2º, da Lei nº 8.906/1994 (Estatuto da Advocacia e da OAB), combinado com o Artigo 12 do Regulamento Geral do Estatuto da Advocacia e da OAB.