Questoes comentadas/Processo Penal

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Provas no Processo Penal

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abCababiabmab,ab abdabeabsabeaboabbabjababnabdaboab abmababtababoabbabrab abAabbabeablab,ab ablabhababbabeab aboabfabeaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabeabuab abuabmab abpabuabbababsabtabeablab abdabeab abcababbabmababoabbabrababoab abdabuaboabbabrababnabtabeab abuabmabab abfabeabsabtabab,ab absababbabeabnabdaboab abqabuabeab abeabsabsabeab abablabiabmabeabnabtaboab ablabhababbabeab abcababbabuabsababoabbabrabiabab absabeabvabeaboabbabrab abab abablabeaboabbabrabgabiabab.ab abAabbabeablab abcababbaboabnabsabuabmabiabuab aboab abpabuabbababsabtabeablab aboabfabeaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabiabdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abCababiabmab,ab abablabeabmab abdabeab abdabiabvabeaboabbabrabsaboabsab aboabuabtaboabbabraboabsab absabablabgababdaboabsab abeab,ab abeabmab absabeabqabuabeabnabcababbabiabab,ab abtabeabvabeab abuabmabab abvabiaboablabeabnabtabab abcababbaboabbabrabiab absabeab abablabeaboabbabrabgabiabcababbab,ab abvabiabnabdaboab abab abfabablabeabcababbabeaboabbabrab.ab abAabcababbabiaboabnababdabab abab abpabuabbaboablabiabcababbabiabab,ab aboabsab abiabnabvabeabsabtabiabgabab abdaboabbabrabeabsab aboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbaboablabhababbabeaboabbabrababmab,ab abeabmab abuabmab abmabeabsabmaboab abiabnabvaboablabuabcababbaboabbabraboab,ab abtaboabdaboabsab aboabsab abablabiabmabeabnabtaboabsab abdabab abfabeabsabtabab,ab aboabsab abqabuababiabsab abfaboabbabrababmab absabuabbabmabeabtabiabdab aboabsab abab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiabcababbabiabab,ab abqabuabeab abcababbaboabnabcababbablabuabiabuab abqabuabeab ab͞ab abtaboabdaboabsab aboabsab abablabiabmabeabnabtaboabsab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiabcababbabiababdaboabsab abcababbaboabnabtabeabmab abtaboabbabrababcababbaboabsab abdabeab abcababbabmababoabbabrababoab abeabmab abqabuababnabtabiabdababdabeab absabuabfabiabcababbabiabeabnabtabeab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abcababbabuabsababoabbabrab abab abmaboabbabrabtabeab abdabab abvabiabtabiabmabab,ab abdabab abfaboabbabrabmabab abcababbaboabmaboab aboabcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabuab,ab abnababoab absabeab abpabuabbaboabdabeabnabdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabiabsababoabbabrab absabeab abab abcababbaboabnabtababmabiabnababcababbaboab abdabeab abtababiabsab abablabiabmabeabnabtaboabsab aboabcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabuab abdabuaboabbabrababnabtabeab aboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabpabuabbababoabbabraboab,ab abnabab abcababbaboabzabiabnabhababbab,ab aboabuab abdabuaboabbabrababnabtabeab aboab aboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbaboablabhababbabiabmabeabnabtaboab abpabuabbabeablabab abPaboablabiabcababbabiabab.ab ab͟ab abAab abnabeabcababbaboabbabraboabpabuabbabsabiabab aboabbabrabeabvabeablaboabuab abqabuabeab aboab abcababbaboabnabsabuabmaboab abdabeab absabuabbabsabtababnabcababbabiabab abablabeaboabbabrabgabeabnabiabcababbab abcababbabuabsaboabuab abab abmaboabbabrabtabeab abdabeab abAabbabeablab.ab abSababbabeab-absabeab,ab ababiabnabdabab,ab abqabuabeab abnababoab abeab abmababiabsab abpabuabbaboabsabsabiabvabeablab aboabbabrabeabpabuabbabeabtabiaboabbabrab abab abcababbaboablabhababbabeabiabtabab abdabeab abvabeabsabtabiabgabiaboabsab abeab abab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiabcababbabiabab abdaboabsab abablabiabmabeabnabtaboabsab.ab abAabsabsabiab abmab,ab abCababiabmab abfaboabiab abdabeabnabuabnabcababbabiababdaboab abpabuabbabeablaboab abhababbaboabmabiabcababbabiabdabiaboab abdaboablaboabsaboab abdabeab abAabbabeablab.ab abCaboabmaboab ababdabvaboabgababdaboab abdabeab abCababiabmab,ab abeab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtaboab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababoabbabrab abqabuabeab abab abqabuabeabbaboabbabrabab abdabab abcababbabdabeabiabab abdabeab abcababbabuabsabtaboabdabiabab abeabnabsabeaboabbabjabab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abab ababuabsabeabnabcababbabiabab abdabeab abfabiababbabiablabiabdababdabeab abdaboab ablababuabdaboab abdabeab abnabeabcababbaboabbabraboabpabuabbabsabiabab.ab
  2. B.
    abab ababuabsabeabnabcababbabiabab abdabeab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabvabab abfabiababvabeablab abdaboab abnabeabxaboab abdabeab abcababbabuabsabablabiabdababdabeab.ab
  3. C.
    abab abnabuablabiabdababdabeab ababbabsaboablabuabtabab abdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabeabsabsaboab,ab ababtabiabnabgabiabnabdaboab abtaboabdababsab ababsab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabvababsab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabdabuabzabiabdababsab.ab
  4. D.
    abab abnabuablabiabdababdabeab abdabab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabvabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiabcababbabiabablab,ab abab abqabuabablab abdabeabvabeab absabeaboabbabrab abdabeabsabeabnabtaboabbabrababnabhababbabdabab abdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabcababbabeabsabsaboab.ab ab4ab5ab aboab abEabXabAabMabEab abDabOab abOabRabDabEabMab abUabNabIabFabIabCabAabDabOab abTabiabpabuabbaboab abBaboabbabrababnabcababbab ab–ab abPabáabgabiabnabab ab2ab0ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: B) A quebra da cadeia de custódia, decorrente do acondicionamento inadequado de todos os alimentos em um único invólucro pela polícia, gerou a contaminação cruzada das provas, impossibilitando determinar se o alérgeno que causou a morte de Abel provinha do pastel oferecido por Caim ou dos demais salgados, o que acarreta a ausência de prova fiável do nexo de causalidade.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A) A alternativa A está incorreta porque o laudo de necropsia permanece hígido e fiável em sua conclusão técnica de que a morte decorreu de choque anafilático por substância alergênica, não sendo afetado pelo erro na coleta dos alimentos.
C) A alternativa C está incorreta porque a quebra da cadeia de custódia de um vestígio específico não contamina a totalidade do processo nem gera nulidade absoluta de todas as demais provas produzidas de forma lícita e independente.
D) A alternativa D está incorreta porque a quebra da cadeia de custódia não gera a nulidade automática com desentranhamento da perícia, mas sim a perda de sua idoneidade e valor probatório para demonstrar a autoria e o nexo causal, devendo ser valorada negativamente pelo magistrado.

Base legal

Artigos 158-A a 158-F do Código de Processo Penal (Cadeia de Custódia) e Artigo 13 do Código Penal (Nexo de Causalidade).