Questoes comentadas/Direito Civil

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Responsabilidade Civil

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abNaboab abuablabtabiabmaboab abdaboabmabiabnabgaboab,ab ababpabuabbaboabsab abuabmabab abpabuabbababoabbabrabtabiabdabab abdabeab abfabuabtabeabbaboablab,ab abAaboabbabrabiababnaboab aboabfabeaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabeabuab abcababbaboabbabraboabnabab abeabmab absabeabuab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabraboab abab:aboababoab,ab absabeabuab abfaboabbabrababtabeaboabbabrabnaboab ababmabiabgaboab.ab abAaboab abtaboabbabrababnabsabiabtababoabbabrab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abcababbabeaboabbabrabtabab ababvabeabnabiabdabab abeabmab abvabeablaboabcababbabiabdababdabeab abmabuabiabtaboab ababcababbabiabmabab abdabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabmabiabtabiabdabab,ab aboab abvabeabiabcababbabuablaboab abcababbaboabnabdabuabzabiabdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abAaboabbabrabiababnaboab abcababbaboablabiabdabiabuab abcababbaboabmab abuabmab abpabuabbaboabsabtabeab.ab:aboababoab,ab abcababbaboabmab abab abcababbaboablabiabsababoab,ab absaboabfaboabbabrabeabuab abgaboabbabrababvabeabsab ablabeabsaboabeabsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abtaboabdaboab abcababbaboabbabrabpabuabbaboab,ab abtabeabnabdaboab abiabnabcababbablabuabsabiabvabeab abqabuabeab ababmabpabuabbabtababoabbabrab abuabmabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabnabab.ab abAab abeabsabpabuabbaboabsabab abdabeab:aboababoab,ab abqabuabeab abeabsabtabab abgaboabbabrababvabiabdabab,ab abfabiabcababbaboabuab abeabxabtaboabbabrabeabmababmabeabnabtabeab ababbabablababdabab,ab abeabnabcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababnabdaboab-absabeab abiabnabtabeaboabbabrabnababdabab abeabmab abUabnabiabdababdabeab abdabeab abTabeaboabbabrababpabuabbabiabab abIabnabtabeabnabsabiabvabab abeabmab abuabmab abhababbaboabsabpabuabbabiabtabablab abpabuabbabbablabiabcababbaboab.ab abAab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbabeabiabtaboab abdaboab abtabeabmabab abdabab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbaboabnabsababbabiablabiabdababdabeab abcababbabiabvabiablab abdabeab abiabnabdabeabnabiabzababoabbabrab ab,ab abcababbaboabmab abbababsabeab abnababsab absabuabmabuablababsab abdaboab abSabuabpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab abTaboabbabrabiabbabuabnabablab abdabeabJabuabsabtabiabcababbab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abEab abpabuabbaboabsabsabiabvabeablab abab abcababbabuabmabuablababcababbaboab abdababsab abiabnabdabeabnabiabzababcababbaboabeabsab abdabeab abdababnaboab abeabsabtabeabtabiabcababbaboab abeab abdababnaboab abmaboabbabrabablab abeabvabeabnabtabuabablabmabeabnabtabeab absaboabfaboabbabrabiabdaboabsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab:aboababoab,ab abeabmab aboabbabrababzababoab abdababsab abgaboabbabrababvabeabsab ablabeabsaboabeabsab absaboabfaboabbabrabiabdababsab abnaboab ababcababbabiabdabeabnabtabeab.ab
  2. B.
    abAab ablabeabgabiabtabiabmabiabdababdabeab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abpabuabbablabeabiabtabeababoabbabrab abab abiabnabdabeabnabiabzababcababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abdababnaboab abmaboabbabrabablab abeab abeabxabcababbablabuabsabiabvabab abdabeab:aboababoab,ab absabeabnabdaboab abiabnababdabmabiabsabsabiabvabeablab abqabuabeab absabuabab abeabsabpabuabbaboabsabab abvabeabnabhababbab abab abpabuabbablabeabiabtabeababoabbabrab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdababsab abeab abdababnaboabsab abpabuabbabeablaboab ababcababbabiabdabeabnabtabeab.ab
  3. C.
    abMabeabsabmaboab abqabuabeab aboab abtaboabbabrababnabsabpabuabbaboabbabrabtabeab aboabbabrabeabablabiabzababdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abAaboabbabrabiababnaboab abtabeabnabhababbab absabiabdaboab abdabeabsabiabnabtabeaboabbabrabeabsabsababdaboab abeab abdabeab absabiabmabpabuabbablabeabsab abcababbaboabbabrabtabeabsabiabab,ab abeablabeab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbaboabnabdabeab aboabbaboabbabjabeabtabiabvababmabeabnabtabeab abpabuabbabeablaboabsab abdababnaboabsab absaboabfaboabbabrabiabdaboabsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab:aboababoab.ab
  4. D.
    abCaboabmaboab absabeab abtaboabbabrababtabab abdabeab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbaboabnabsababbabiablabiabdababdabeab abcababbabiabvabiablab abeabxabtaboabbabrababcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrababtabuabablab,ab aboabsab abeabvabeabnabtabuababiabsab abdababnaboabsab absaboabfaboabbabrabiabdaboabsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab:aboababoab abgabeaboabbabrababmab aboabbabjabuaboabbabraboabsab abmaboabbabrababtaboabbabrabiaboabsab abeab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbaboab abmaboabnabeabtababoabbabrabiabab abab abpabuabbababoabbabrabtabiaboabbabrab abdaboab abtaboabbabrababnabsabiabtaboab abeabmab aboabbabjabuablabgababdaboab abdabab absabeabnabtabeabnabcababbab.ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa A está correta porque, nos termos da Súmula 387 do STJ, é lícita a cumulação das indenizações de dano estético e dano moral decorrentes do mesmo fato, desde que tenham fundamentos distintos e sejam passíveis de identificação autônoma.

Por que as demais estão erradas:

A alternativa B está incorreta porque a jurisprudência do STJ consagra a legitimidade dos parentes mais próximos para pleitear indenização por dano moral reflexo ou por ricochete, decorrente do sofrimento gerado pelo acidente da vítima direta.

A alternativa C está incorreta porque, segundo a Súmula 145 do STJ, no transporte desinteressado ou de simples cortesia, o transportador não responde objetivamente, mas sim subjetivamente mediante a comprovação de dolo ou culpa grave.

A alternativa D está incorreta porque, na responsabilidade extracontratual, os juros moratórios fluem a partir do evento danoso (Súmula 54 do STJ) e a correção monetária do dano moral incide desde a data do arbitramento (Súmula 362 do STJ), e não do trânsito em julgado.

Base legal

Súmulas 54, 145, 362 e 387 do Superior Tribunal de Justiça (STJ).