Questoes comentadas/Direito Constitucional

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Direitos e Garantias Fundamentais

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abAab abFababcababbabuablabdababdabeab abdabeab abDabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboab abdabab abUabnabiabvabeaboabbabrabsabiabdababdabeab abdaboab abEabsabtababdaboab abBabeabtabab,ab abpabuabbabeablabab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabmabeabiaboabbabrabab abvabeabzab,ab abpabuabbabbablabiabcababbaboabuab abeabdabiabtabablab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab aboab abiabnabgaboabbabrabeabsabsaboab abnaboabsab abcababbabuaboabbabrabsaboabsab abdabeab abmabeabsabtaboabbabrababdaboab abeab abdaboabuabtaboabbabrababdaboab,ab abcababbaboabnabtabeabnabdaboab absabiabsabtabeabmabab abdabeab abcababbaboabtababsab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abgaboabbabrababdabuababdaboabsab abnabeabgaboabbabraboabsab,ab abiabnabdabiabgabeabnababsab,ab abqabuabiablaboabmabbaboablababsab abeab abpabuabbabeabsabsaboababsab abcababbaboabmab abdabeabfabiabcababbabiabeabnabcababbabiabab.ab abOab abeabdabiab abtabablab abbababsabeabiabab-absabeab abeabmab ablabeabiab abeabsabtababdabuabablab,ab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabmabuablabgababdabab abnaboab ababnaboab abpabuabbababsabsababdaboab,ab abqabuabeab abgababoabbabrababnabtabeab,ab abpabuabbabeablaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrababzaboab abdabeab abcababbabiabnabcababbaboab ababnaboabsab,ab aboab ababcababbabeabsabsaboab abdabiabfabeaboabbabrabeabnabcababbabiababdaboab ababoabsab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabgaboabbabrababmababsab abdabeab abmabeabsabtaboabbabrababdaboab abeab abdaboabuabtaboabbabrababdaboab.ab abIabnabdabiabgabnababdaboab abcababbaboabmab abeabsabsabab aboabbabrabeabgaboabbabrabab,ab abuabmab abgaboabbabrababdabuababdaboab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtaboabuab abpabuabbabeabdabiabdaboab ababdabmabiabnabiabsabtaboabbabrababtabiabvaboab abvabiabsababnabdaboab abab abmaboabdabiabfabiabcababbabcababbaboab abdaboab abeabdabiabtabablab,ab abcababbaboabmab abab abeabxabcababbablabuabsababoab abdaboab absabiabsabtabeabmabab abdabeab abcababbaboabtababsab.ab abPababoabbabrabab abtababnabtaboab,ab ababoabbabrabgabuabmabeabnabtaboabuab abqabuabeab abeablabeab abvabiaboablabab aboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabnabcababbabiabpabuabbab abiaboab abdabab abiabsaboabnaboabmabiabab.ab abDabiababnabtabeab abdabab abpabuabbaboablabeabmabiabcababbab,ab abab abDabiaboabbabrabeabtaboabbabrabab abdabab abFababcababbabuablabdababdabeab abcababbaboabnabsabuablabtaboabuab aboab abcababbaboabbabrabpabuabbaboab abdabeab ababdabvaboabgababdaboabsab abdabab abUabnabiabvabeaboabbabrabsabiabdababdabeab.ab abSaboabbaboabbabrabeab abab abhababbabiabpabuabbaboabtabeabsabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdabab,ab absabeabgabuabnabdaboab aboab absabiabsabtabeabmabab aboabbabjabuaboabbabrabiabdabiabcababbaboab-ab abcababbaboabnabsabtabiabtabuabcababbabiaboabnabablab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabraboab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab aboabpabuabbabcababbaboab abqabuabeab abiabnabdabiabcababbab aboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabeab aboabbabrab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtaboab abqabuabeab abdabeabvabeab absabeaboabbabrab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdaboab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abOab ababcababbabeabsabsaboab abdabiabfabeaboabbabrabeabnabcababbabiababdaboab,ab abcababbaboabmaboab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdaboab abnaboab abeabdabiabtabablab,ab absaboab abpabuabbaboabdabeab absabeaboabbabrab ababdabmabiabtabiabdaboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab ababsab abeabdabuabcababbabcababbaboabeabsab abbababsabiabcababbab abeab absabuabpabuabbabeaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab,ab absabeabnabdaboab abeabxabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabsababmabeabnabtabeab abvabeabdababdabab abab absabuabab abuabtabiablabiabzababcababbaboab abeabmab abcababbabuaboabbabrabsaboabsab abdabeab abpabuabbaboabsab-ab abgaboabbabrababdabuababcababbaboab.ab
  2. B.
    abAab abdabiaboabbabrabeabtaboabbabrabiabab abdabab abFababcababbabuablabdababdabeab abdabeab abDabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboab abtabeabmab abdabiabsabcababbaboabbabrabiabcababbabiaboabnababoabbabrabiabeabdababdabeab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab,ab ablabiabvaboabbabrabeabmabeabnabtabeab,ab abeabsabtababbabeablabeabcababbabeaboabbabrab abcababbaboabbabrabiabtabeaboabbabrabiaboabsab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab aboab ababcababbabeabsabsaboab ababoabsab abcababbabuaboabbabrabsaboabsab abdabeab abgaboabbabrababdabuababcababbaboab abeab abpabuabbaboabsab-abgaboabbabrababdabuababcababbaboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abqabuababiabsabqabuabeaboabbabrab abgaboabbabrabuabpabuabbaboabsab absaboabcababbabiababiabsab,ab abcababbaboabmab abbababsabeab abnabab ababuabtaboabnaboabmabiabab abdabiabdababtabiabcababbaboab-abcababbabiabeabnabtabiabfabiabcababbab abeab ababdabmabiabnabiabsabtaboabbabrababtabiabvabab abdabeab abqabuabeab abgaboabzababmab ababsab abuabnabiabvabeaboabbabrabsabiabdababdabeabsab abpabuabbabbablabiabcababbabsab.ab
  3. C.
    abAab aboabbabrabeabablabiabzababcababbaboab abdabab abdabiabmabeabnabsababoab abmababtabeaboabbabrabiabablab abdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabnabcababbabiabpabuabbabiaboab abdabab abiabgabuabablabdababdabeab abcababbaboababdabuabnabab-absabeab abcababbaboabmab abab ababdaboabcababbaboab abdabeab ababcababbaboabeabsab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvababsab abqabuabeab ababtabiabnaboabbabjabab abgaboabbabrabuabpabuabbaboabsab absaboabcababbabiababiabsab abdabeabtabeaboabbabrabmabiabnababdaboabsab,ab ababtaboabbabrabiabbabuabiabnabdaboab-ablabhababbabeabsab abcababbabeaboabbabrabtababsab abvababnabtababgabeabnabsab,ab abnaboabbabrabmabablabmabeabnabtabeab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abtabeabmabpabuabbaboab abdabeabfabiabnabiabdaboab,ab abcababbaboabmab abvabiabsabtababsab abab absabuabpabuabbabeaboabbabrababcababbaboab abdabeab abdabeabsabiabgabuabablabdababdabeabsab abdabeabcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabnabtabeabsab abdabeab absabiabtabuababcababbaboabeabsab abhababbabiabsabtaboabbabrabiabcababbabsab.ab
  4. D.
    abOab abeabdabiabtabablab abeablababbaboabbabrababdaboab abpabuabbabeablabab abFababcababbabuablabdababdabeab abdabeab abDabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboab abvabiaboablabab aboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabnabcababbabiabpabuabbabiaboab abdabab abiabsaboabnaboabmabiabab abfaboabbabrabmabablab,ab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabnabcababbabiabpabuabbabiaboab abcababbaboabnabsabtabiabtabuabcababbabiaboabnabablab abeablabeabmabeabnabtababoabbabrab,ab abqabuabeab abtabeabmab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abfabuabnabcababbaboab abgababoabbabrababnabtabiaboabbabrab abiabdabeabnabtabiabcababbabsab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab abdabeab ababcababbabeabsabsaboab ababoab abeabnabsabiabnaboab abdabeab abpabuabbaboabsab-abgaboabbabrababdabuababcababbaboab abab abtaboabdaboabsab,ab aboabbabrabeablababtabiabvabiabzababnabdaboab abpabuabbaboabsabsabiabvabeabiabsab abdabiabfabeaboabbabrabeabnabcababbabsab abcababbabuablabtabuaboabbabrababiabsab,ab abdabeab aboabbabrababcababbab aboabuab abmabeabsabmaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abdabeabfabiabcababbabiabeabnabcababbabiabab.ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa C está correta porque a adoção de ações afirmativas, como o sistema de cotas temporário instituído por lei estadual, visa concretizar a igualdade em sua dimensão material (substancial), tratando os desiguais na medida de suas desigualdades para superar distorções históricas de exclusão social.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A alternativa A está incorreta porque não há vedação constitucional ou legal à aplicação de ações afirmativas na pós-graduação, sendo estas legítimas para garantir o pluralismo e a igualdade de oportunidades em todos os níveis de ensino.
A alternativa B está incorreta porque a autonomia universitária (art. 207 da CF) não confere discricionariedade ilimitada ou livre para criar critérios de acesso sem amparo na legalidade e nos direitos fundamentais.
A alternativa D está incorreta porque o edital não viola a isonomia, mas sim a concretiza sob o prisma material, superando a insuficiência da igualdade meramente formal que desconsidera as barreiras históricas enfrentadas por minorias.

Base legal

Artigo 5º, caput, da Constituição Federal de 1988; Entendimento do STF na ADPF 186 e na ADC 41, que reconhecem a constitucionalidade das ações afirmativas como mecanismos de promoção da igualdade material.