Questoes comentadas/Direito Constitucional

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Nacionalidade

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abDababoabbabrabiababnabab,ab abqabuabeab abnababsabcababbabeabuab abnaboab abBaboabbabrababsabiablab,ab abdabeabcababbabiabdabiabuab ababdabqabuabiaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abdabeab abuabmab abpabuabbababiabsab ababsabiababtabiabcababbaboab.ab abEabmabbaboabbabrabab abeabsabtabeab abpabuabbabab abiabsab abnababoab abtabiabvabeabsabsabeab abiabmabpabuabbaboabsabtaboab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab absabuabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabmababnabeabnabcababbabiabab abnaboab aboabbabrabeabsabpabuabbabeabcababbabtabiabvaboab abtabeaboabbabraboabbabrabiabtaboabbabrabiaboab aboabuab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab aboab abeabxabeaboabbabrabcababbabiabcababbabiaboab abdaboabsab abdabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboabsab abcababbabiabvabiabsab,ab abeablabab ababcababbaboabbabrabeabdabiabtababvabab abqabuabeab abeabsabsabab abdabeabcababbabiabsababoab abfababcababbabiablabiabtababoabbabrabiabab absabuabab abcababbabiaboabbabrabcababbabuablababcababbaboab abpabuabbabeablaboab abcababbaboabnabtabiabnabeabnabtabeab ababsabiababtabiabcababbaboab,ab aboabbabjabab abqabuabeab abtabiabnabhababbab aboab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabiabtaboab abdab abeab abeabxabpabuabbablaboabbabrababoabbabrab abvababoabbabrabiaboabsab absabiabtabiaboabsab abmaboabnabtababnabhababbaboabsaboabsab.ab abNaboab abeabnabtababnabtaboab,ab ababoab aboabbabrabeabtaboabbabrabnababoabbabrab ababoab abBaboabbabrababsabiablab abnabeabsabtabeab abmabeabsab,ab abDababoabbabrabiababnabab abfaboabiab abiabnabfaboabbabrabmababdabab abdabeab abqabuabeab abeabsabsabab abeabsabcababbaboablabhababbab abpabuabbaboabdabeab aboabbabrabeabsabuablabtababoabbabrab abnabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabab abdabeab absabuabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab.ab abPaboabbabrabeaboabcababbabuabpabuabbababdabab,ab abeablabab abcababbaboabnabsabuablabtaboabuab abvaboabcababbabeab,ab abcababbaboabmaboab ababdabvaboabgababdaboab(abab)ab,ab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abeabsabcababbablababoabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabeaboabbabrab abab absabuabab absabiabtabuababcababbaboab,ab abeabxabpabuabbablabiabcababbabnabdaboab abqabuabeab abnabuabnab abcababbab aboabbabrabeabablabiabzaboabuab abqabuabablabqabuabeaboabbabrab abpabuabbabeabdabiabdaboab abeabxabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabsaboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab ababbabdabiabcababbaboabbabrab abdabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab.ab abSaboabbaboabbabrabeab abab absabiabtabuababcababbaboab abdabeab abDababoabbabrabiababnabab,ab abdabeab ababcababbaboabbabrabdaboab abcababbaboabmab aboab absabiabsabtabeabmabab aboabbabjabuaboabbabrabiabdabiabcababbaboab-ab abcababbaboabnabsabtabiabtabuabcababbabiaboabnabablab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabraboab,ab abab absabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abEablabab abmababnabtabeabmab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab,ab abnaboab abcababbabsaboab abeabmab ababnabablabiabsabeab,ab ababpabuabbabeabnababsab aboab abpabuabbabeabdabiabdaboab abeabxabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabsaboab abdabeab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabab abdabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abpabuabbaboabdabeab abgabeaboabbabrababoabbabrab abtabablab abcababbaboabnabsabeabqabuabeabnabcababbabiabab.ab
  2. B.
    abEablabab abnababoab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabeab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab,ab abdabeabsabdabeab abqabuabeab abcababbaboabmabuabnabiabqabuab abeab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabvabiababmabeabnabtabeab ababoab abgaboabvabeaboabbabrabnaboab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabraboab abqabuabeab abnababoab abdabeabsabeaboabbabjabab aboabbabrabeabnabuabnabcababbabiababoabbabrab abab abeablabab ababoab ababdabqabuabiaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab abab abnaboabvabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab.ab
  3. C.
    abEablabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabeab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab ababpabuabbabeabnababsab absabeab abdabeabiabxababoabbabrab abdabeab abeabxabeaboabbabrabcababbabeaboabbabrab abdabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboabsab abpabuabbaboablabiabtabiabcababbaboabsab abeab abcababbabiabvabiabsab abnaboab abBaboabbabrababsabiablab,ab abcababbaboabmaboab aboab abvaboabtaboab aboabuab abab abmababnabuabtabeabnabcababbaboab abdabeab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabbabrabiabeabdababdabeabsab,ab ababpabuabbaboabsab ababdabqabuabiaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab abab abnaboabvabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab.ab
  4. D.
    abEablabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabeab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab abbaboabbabrababsabiablabeabiaboabbabrabab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab ababoab ababdabqabuabiaboabbabrabiaboabbabrab abvaboablabuabnabtababoabbabrabiababmabeabnabtabeab aboabuabtaboabbabrabab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab,ab absabeabmab abiabmabpabuabbaboabsabiabcababbaboab abdaboab abEabsabtababdaboab abeabsabtaboabbabrababnabgabeabiaboabbabraboab,ab abeablabab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabdabeab ababuabtaboabmababtabiabcababbabmabeabnabtabeab abab abnababcababbabiaboabnabablabiabdababdabeab aboabbabrabiabgabiabnababoabbabrabiabab.ab ab4ab5ab aboab abEabXabAabMabEab abDabOab abOabRabDabEabMab abUabNabIabFabIabCabAabDabOab abTabiabpabuabbaboab abBaboabbabrababnabcababbab ab–ab abPabáabgabiabnabab ab7ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa A está correta porque, com a promulgação da Emenda Constitucional nº 131/2023, a perda da nacionalidade brasileira decorrente da aquisição de outra nacionalidade passou a exigir o pedido expresso de renúncia por parte do cidadão, não ocorrendo mais de forma automática pela mera naturalização voluntária.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A alternativa B está incorreta porque a manutenção da nacionalidade brasileira é a regra e não depende de qualquer comunicação prévia ou notificação ao governo brasileiro.
A alternativa C está incorreta porque a perda da nacionalidade não possui qualquer relação com o não exercício de direitos políticos ou civis no território nacional.
A alternativa D está incorreta porque reflete a regra anterior à EC nº 131/2023; atualmente, a aquisição voluntária de outra nacionalidade não gera a perda automática da nacionalidade brasileira originária.

Base legal

Artigo 12, § 4º, inciso II, da Constituição Federal de 1988 (redação dada pela Emenda Constitucional nº 131/2023).