Questoes comentadas/Direito Civil

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Contratos em Espécie

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

abAab absaboabcababbabiabeabdababdabeab abeabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsababoabbabrabiabab abEablabeabtaboabbabrabiabcababbab abPababsabsabab abSabeabtabeab abLabtabdabab.ab,ab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abmabeabiaboab abdabeab absabeabuab ababdabmabiabnabiabsabtaboabbabrababdaboabbabrab,ab ababoabbabjabuabiabzaboabuab abtabeabmabpabuabbabeabsabtabiabvababmabeabnabtabeab ababcababbaboab aboabbabrabeabnaboabvababtaboabbabrabiabab abdabeab ablaboabcababbabcababbaboab abnababoab aboabbabrabeabsabiabdabeabnabcababbabiabablab aboabbabrabeabfabeaboabbabrabeabnabtabeab ababoab abiabmaboabvabeablab aboabnabdabeab abeabsabtabab ablaboabcababbablabiabzababdabab abab abfabiablabiabablab abnabab abcababbabiabdababdabeab abdabeab abVababoabbabrabgabiabnabhababbab,ab abMabGab.ab abEabab abpabuabbabeabtabiabcababbaboab abiabnabiabcababbabiabablab,ab abab ababuabtaboabbabrabab abiabnabdab abiabcababbaboabuab ababsab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab aboabfabeaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabiabdababsab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab aboabbabrabeabnaboabvababcababbaboab abdabab ablaboabcababbabcababbaboab,ab abeabsabpabuabbabeabcababbabiabablabmabeabnabtabeab aboab abnaboabvaboab abvabablaboabbabrab abdaboab abablabuabgabuabeablab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabtaboab.ab abAabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdabab abab abcababbaboabnabtabeabsabtababcababbaboab,ab aboab ablaboabcababbabdaboabbabrab abiabnabfaboabbabrabmaboabuab abqabuabeab aboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabeabbabeabuab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabtabab abdabeab abtabeaboabbabrabcababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab abnaboabvabab ablaboabcababbabcababbaboab abeabmab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab abmabeablabhababbaboabbabrabeabsab abdaboab abqabuabeab ababqabuabeablababsab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabtababsab abpabuabbabeablabab ablaboabcababbabtababoabbabrabiabab abnabab abpabuabbabeabtabiabcababbaboab abiabnabiabcababbabiabablab,ab absabeabnab abdaboab aboab abvabablaboabbabrab ablaboabcababbabtabiabvaboab abdaboab abiabmaboabvabeablab ab1ab2abйab abmababiaboabbabrab abdaboab abqabuabeab aboab aboabfabeaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabiabdaboab abpabuabbabeablabab ablaboabcababbabtababoabbabrabiabab.ab abCaboabnabsabiabdabeaboabbabrababdaboabsab aboabsab abfababtaboabsab abnababoabbabraboabbabrababdaboabsab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    abOab ablaboabcababbabdaboabbabrab abnababoab abpabuabbaboabdabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababoabbabrab abnabab abcababbaboabnabtabeabsabtababcababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabtabab abdabeab abtabeaboabbabrabcababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab ablaboabcababbabcababbaboab,ab ababiabnabdabab abqabuabeab abeabmab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab abmabeablabhababbaboabbabrabeabsab,ab abdabiababnabtabeab abdaboab abdabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboab abpabuabbaboabtabeabsabtababtabiabvaboab abdaboab ablaboabcababbabtababoabbabrabiaboab abab aboabbabrabeabnaboabvababcababbaboab abcababbaboabmabpabuabbablabsaboabbabrabiabab.ab
  2. B.
    abAab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabsabtabab abdabeab abtabeaboabbabrabcababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbaboabdabeab absabeaboabbabrab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdabab abeabmab abdaboabcababbabuabmabeabnabtaboab abpabuabbabbablabiabcababbaboab aboabuab abpabuabbababoabbabrabtabiabcababbabuablababoabbabrab.ab abCababsaboab aboab abdaboabcababbabuabmabeabnabtaboab absabeaboabbabjabab abpabuabbababoabbabrabtabiabcababbabuablababoabbabrab abeab abeabsabtabeaboabbabjabab abcababbaboabmab ababsabsabiabnababtabuaboabbabrabab ababuabtabeabnabtabiabcababbabdabab,ab abeab abdabiabsabpabuabbabeabnabsababvabeablab abab abiabnabtabeaboabbabrabvabeabnabcababbaboab abdabeab abtabeabsabtabeabmabuabnabhababbabsab.ab
  3. C.
    abOab ablaboabcababbabtababoabbabrabiaboab abpabuabbaboabdabeaboabbabrabab,ab abeabmab aboabbabrabeabpabuabbablabiabcababbab,ab abmababnabiabfabeabsabtababoabbabrab ababoab ablaboabcababbabdaboabbabrab abqabuabeab ababcababbabeabiabtabab ababsab abcababbaboabnabdabiabcababbaboabeabsab ababpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabeabnabtababdababsab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abtabeaboabbabrabcababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab aboabbabtabeaboabbabrab abab aboabbabrabeabnaboabvababcababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabtabeabnabdabiabdabab.ab
  4. D.
    abOab aboabbabrababmaboab abdabeab abnabeabgaboabcababbabiaboab abab absabeaboabbabrab abeabxabpabuabbablaboabbabrababdaboab abpabuabbabeablaboab abtabeaboabbabrabcababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabnabeabnabtabeab abpabuabbaboabdabeab aboabuab abnababoab absabeaboabbabrab aboab abmabeabsabmaboab abdaboab ablaboabcababbabtababoabbabrabiaboab,ab abdabeabsabdabeab abqabuabeab absabeaboabbabjabab abeabxabpabuabbablaboabbabrababdaboab abcababbaboabnabtabiabnabuababdababmabeabnabtabeab abnaboabsab abuablabtabiabmaboabsab abtaboabbabrabeabsab ababnaboabsab.ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa C está correta porque, nos termos do Art. 72, § 1º, da Lei nº 8.245/1991 (Lei do Inquilinato), caso o locador apresente proposta de terceiro com melhores condições, o locatário tem a faculdade de, em réplica, aceitar essas mesmas condições propostas pelo terceiro para garantir a renovação do contrato de locação.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A alternativa A está incorreta porque o Art. 72, inciso III, da Lei nº 8.245/1991 autoriza expressamente o locador a alegar em contestação a existência de proposta de terceiro em condições mais vantajosas.
A alternativa B está incorreta porque o Art. 72, § 2º, exige que a proposta de terceiro seja subscrita por este e por duas testemunhas, não havendo dispensa de testemunhas pela mera autenticação de assinatura.
A alternativa D está incorreta porque o Art. 72, § 2º, veda expressamente que o ramo de negócio a ser explorado pelo terceiro seja o mesmo do locatário.

Base legal

Artigo 72, inciso III, § 1º e § 2º, da Lei nº 8.245/1991 (Lei do Inquilinato)