Questoes comentadas/Direito Penal

Questao comentada gratuita

Questão comentada sobre Teoria do Crime

Enunciado, alternativas e comentario aberto para indexacao, revisao e conexao com aulas e materiais relevantes.

FGV202545º Exame de Ordem Unificado - Prova Tipo 1

Enunciado

ab:aboababoab abeab abmabiabsabsabiaboabnababoabbabrabiaboab,ab abeab abPabeabdaboabbabraboab abeab abpabuabbababsabtaboabbabrab,ab ababmabbaboabsab abdabab abmabeabsabmabab abiabgaboabbabrabeaboabbabjabab.ab abOab abpabuabbaboabbabrabiabmabeabiaboabbabraboab abpabuabbablababnabeaboabbabjaboabuab ababpabuabbaboabbabraboabpabuabbaboabbabrabiababoabbabrab-absabeab abdaboab abdabiabnabhababbabeabiaboabbabraboab abdaboabsab abdabiabzabiabmaboabsab abqabuabeab abPabeabdaboabbabraboab abcababbaboabsabtabuabmababvabab abgabuababoabbabrabdababoabbabrab abeabmab abuabmabab abuaboabbabrabnabab abeabmab absabeabuab abqabuababoabbabrabtaboab,ab ablaboabcababbablabiabzababdaboab abnaboabsab abfabuabnabdaboabsab abdabab abiabgaboabbabrabeaboabbabjabab.ab abQabuababnabdaboab abPabeabdaboabbabraboab absabeab ababuabsabeabnabtaboabuab abdabuaboabbabrababnabtabeab abab abnaboabiabtabeab,ab:aboababoab abpabuabbablaboabuab aboab abmabuaboabbabraboab abeab ababoabbabraboabbabraboabmabbaboabuab abab abfabeabcababbabhababbabdabuaboabbabrabab,ab abmababsab,ab ababoab absabeab ababpabuabbaboabbabraboabxabiabmababoabbabrab abdabab abuaboabbabrabnabab,ab abfaboabiab abtaboabmababdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abuabmab absabeabnabtabiabmabeabnabtaboab absaboabbaboabbabrabeabnababtabuaboabbabrabablab,ab aboabbabraboabuab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab ablabiabvaboabbabrababoabbabrab-absabeab abdaboabsab abmababuabsab abpabuabbabeabnabsababmabeabnabtaboabsab abeab abfaboabiab abeabmabbaboabbabrabab.ab abSaboabbaboabbabrabeab abab ababcababbaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrababtabiabcababbabdabab abpabuabbaboabbabrab:aboababoab,ab ababsabsabiabnabablabeab abab ababfabiaboabbabrabmababtabiabvabab abcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabtabab.ab

Alternativas

  1. A.
    ab:aboababoab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabeabuab ababsab abfababsabeabsab abdabab abcababbaboabgabiabtababcababbaboab,ab abpabuabbaboabbabrabeabpabuabbababoabbabrababcababbaboab abeab abeabxabeabcababbabuabcababbaboab,ab abqabuabeab abiabnabtabeabgaboabbabrababmab aboab abiabtabeaboabbabrab abcababbaboabbabrabiabmabiabnabiabsab ab,ab abmababsab abnababoab abeabxababuaboabbabrabiabuab abab abcababbaboabnabdabuabtabab,ab aboab abqabuabeab abeaboabbabrabab abiabmabpabuabbaboabbabrabeabsabcababbabiabnabdabiabvabeablab abpabuabbababoabbabrabab abab abcababbaboabbabrababcababbabtabeaboabbabrabiabzababcababbaboab abdabab abtabeabnabtababtabiabvabab.ab
  2. B.
    ab:aboababoab abpabuabbaboabbabrababtabiabcababbaboabuab abtabeabnabtababtabiabvabab abdabeab abfabuaboabbabrabtaboab abeab absabeaboabbabrab-ablabhababbabeab-abab ababpabuabbablabiabcababbabdabab abab abpabuabbabeabnabab abdaboab abcababbaboabbabrabiabmabeab abcababbaboabnabsabuabmababdaboab abab absabeaboabbabrab aboabbabrabeabdabuabzabiabdabab,ab abdabeabnabtaboabbabraboab abdababsab abmababoabbabrabgabeabnabsab ablabeabgababiabsab,ab absabeabgabuabnabdaboab aboab abtaboabbabrabeabcabeabbababbabhababbaboab abdaboab abiabtabeaboabbabrab abcababbaboabbabrabiabmabiabnabiabsab abqabuabeab abfaboabiab abpabuabbabeaboabbabrabcababbaboabbabraboabbabrabiabdaboab.ab
  3. C.
    ab:aboababoab abpabuabbaboabbabrababtabiabcababbaboabuab abtabeabnabtababtabiabvabab abiabmabpabuabbabeaboabbabrabfabeabiabtabab abdabeab abfabuaboabbabrabtaboab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab,ab ababpabuabbabeabsababoabbabrab abdabeab abtabeaboabbabrab abpabuabbaboabbabrababtabiabcababbabdaboab abtaboabdaboabsab aboabsab ababtaboabsab abeabxabeabcababbabuabtaboabbabrabiaboabsab,ab aboab aboabbabrabeabsabuablabtababdaboab abnababoab abfaboabiab ababtabiabnabgabiabdaboab abpabuabbaboabbabrab abcababbabiaboabbabrabcababbabuabnabsabtababnabcababbabiababsab absaboabbaboabbabrabeabnababtabuaboabbabrababiabsab ababvabeabsabsababsab abab abvaboabnabtababdabeab abdaboab ababgabeabnabtabeab.ab
  4. D.
    ab:aboababoab abcababbaboabnabsabuabmaboabuab aboab abcababbaboabbabrabiabmabeab abdabeab abvabiaboablababcababbaboab abdabeab abdaboabmabiabcababbabiablabiaboab,ab abpabuabbaboabiabsab,ab abdabeab abmababnabeabiaboabbabrabab ablabiabvaboabbabrabeab abeab abcababbaboabnabsabcababbabiabeabnabtabeab,ab abiabnabgaboabbabrabeabsabsaboabuab abnabab abcababbabsabab abablabhababbabeabiabab abcababbaboabnabtaboabbabrabab abab abvaboabnabtababdabeab abdabeab abqabuabeabmab abdabeab abdabiaboabbabrabeabiabtaboab.ab

Gabarito: alternativa correta destacada.

Comentario

Correta: A alternativa D está correta porque, ao desistir voluntariamente de prosseguir com a subtração do dinheiro (art. 15 do CP), João responde apenas pelos atos já praticados. Como ele ingressou no quarto de Pedro (que constitui compartimento habitado, equiparado a domicílio pelo art. 150, § 4º, II, do CP), restou consumado o crime de violação de domicílio.

Por que as demais estão erradas:
A) A alternativa A está incorreta porque a desistência voluntária impede a caracterização da tentativa de furto, fazendo com que o agente responda apenas pelos atos residuais já consumados.
B) A alternativa B está incorreta porque a desistência voluntária afasta a tentativa de furto, não havendo que se falar em aplicação de pena de furto reduzida.
C) A alternativa C está incorreta porque a interrupção da conduta decorreu do próprio ato de vontade do agente (desistência voluntária), e não de circunstâncias alheias à sua vontade, o que afasta a tentativa (imperfeita ou perfeita).

Base legal

Artigo 15 (Desistência Voluntária) e Artigo 150, § 4º, inciso II (Violação de Domicílio), ambos do Código Penal Brasileiro.